One of the most practical threads in the 2026 ANBA State of the Industry report is about money: what alcohol-free drinks cost, what they earn, and what people will pay. The picture that emerges is a category with two different pricing stories depending on where you buy, and a clear signal that one of them is leaving money on the table.
The median alcohol-free cocktail is priced 30.8 percent below one with alcohol, yet the average drinker says they would pay more for it than the alcoholic version costs.
In stores, alcohol-free holds a real premium. The average alcohol-free item sells for 11.07 dollars against 9.31 for an alcoholic one, and that premium rose in the latest year while alcohol prices slipped. Measured properly by volume, Circana finds alcohol-free beer sells for 16.3 percent more than beer overall and alcohol-free wine 25.6 percent more than wine overall. People are paying up for the alcohol-free version on the shelf.
The brands are healthy on those prices. 72 percent of surveyed alcohol-free brands report gross margins of 40 percent or more, and 36 percent are at 50 percent or higher. Tellingly, only 17 percent of brands name price competition and margins as a top-three challenge, far fewer than the 57 percent who struggle with getting onto retail shelves. The problem is distribution, not pricing power.
On restaurant menus, though, the story flips. The median alcohol-free cocktail costs 9 dollars against 13 for one with alcohol, a 30.8 percent discount. Alcohol-free beer is priced much closer to its alcoholic counterpart, at 6.50 against 7.00, just 7.1 percent less. The gap is specifically in cocktails, where operators are still treating the alcohol-free version as a lesser drink and pricing it like one.
What makes that discount look like a mistake is what drinkers say they will pay. Among people who have tried low- and no-alcohol drinks, roughly half say they expect to pay less, but 37.6 percent expect to pay the same and 12.9 percent expect to pay more. Asked the most they would spend on a mocktail at a casual bar or restaurant, the average answer was 13.43 dollars, which is more than the median menu price of a cocktail with alcohol. Datassential, which gathered the menu data, flatly sees room for operators to price alcohol-free cocktails closer to their alcoholic ones.
The reason the gap persists is an old assumption: that a drink without alcohol must be cheaper because the expensive part is missing. But the alcohol was rarely the expensive part. The fresh juice, the house syrups, the labor, the garnish, the time, and the alcohol-free spirit itself, which is not cheap, all remain. A well-made alcohol-free cocktail costs about the same to build as its alcoholic twin, which is exactly why charging a third less for it quietly erodes the margin on every one sold.
The Cr(af)ted Take
If you run a bar or restaurant, the report hands you a small raise. Your alcohol-free cocktail costs nearly what your alcoholic one does to make, your guests have told researchers they would pay roughly the same for it, and you are discounting it by almost a third out of habit. Pricing it within a dollar or two of the alcoholic version is not gouging; it is correcting an accidental markdown, and the data says your guests will not flinch.
For drinkers, the takeaway is the counterpart. When a thoughtful bar charges 12 or 14 dollars for an alcohol-free cocktail, that is not a rip-off for leaving the alcohol out; it is the price of everything that is still in the glass, made by someone who put the same care into it. The category has earned its premium on the shelf. The menu is the last place that premium has to catch up. For the wider context, see our overview of the 2026 ANBA report.
Original reporting: ANBA →